Sarah
8/10
United Kingdom 🇬🇧
Would be staying again and recommending
Pros: The room was very spacious, and comfortable. The location was excellent. The hotel bar was perfect, with the cocktail list! The staff were always very pleasant and helpful
Cons: The lighting in the room was very poor. There was no vanity mirror in the room itself, only a floor length mirror and the lighting on this mirror was not suitable for makeup application.
Grace
10/10
United Kingdom 🇬🇧
One of the most welcoming hotels in the centre of the city
Pros: Comfortable bed, balcony and very friendly and polite staff
Cons: Maybe I should have asked so I am not going to blame, but lack of drinking water not visible
Michael
8/10
United Kingdom 🇬🇧
Great hotel in excellent location
Pros: The staff were very accommodating and friendly. The room was spacious and very clean. The bed was super comfy, nice bathroom. Excellent location
Cons: The air con was extremely noisey and had to switch it off over night.
Deborah
9/10
United Kingdom 🇬🇧
A brilliant return to NY after many years was made even more special by the Gotham Hotel
Pros: Location. Bed was super comfortable. Shower had good pressure. Room was the perfect size for a visit to NY. Clean. The staff were informal in a very professional manner.
Cons: The loo didn’t always flush first time. No boiling water to make a cup of tea
Sharon
9/10
United States 🇺🇸
Simply lovely!
Pros: Loved the location, walking distance to Grand Central Station and other attractions, and the boutique size of the hotel. We also loved its unique architectural features, and the on-site restaurant is excellent. The outdoor decks on upper levels are cozy places to enjoy the midtown scenery. We totally enjoyed our stay and our interactions with the professional staff at the Gotham. Will definitely keep The Gotham Hotel on our list of top choices for a stay in NYC and recommend it to others.
Cons: Our only complaints are that the TV reception wasn't the best, and the bathroom had no towel bars. Also, updated phone charges are needed on the nightstands.
Ektor
10/10
Brazil 🇧🇷
Very good place to be
Pros: Fast checkin and checkout, comfortable and clean rooms, very well located at Midtown Manhattan
Cons: Fullfilled all expectations
Ian
9/10
United Kingdom 🇬🇧
Great stay, a little noisy
Pros: The room was clean and spacious with housekeeping every day..
Cons: Not sure it's the hotels fault but each morning, we were woken very early with the sound of bin lorries (which we understand but noisy) and on one morning a lorry was sitting outside for a good 25 minutes with it's engine running.. we were on the 5th floor facing the street.