The Renwick

Lovely New Year, New York break

Pros: This is a funky, heritage hotel in a brilliant location. The staff went above and beyond to make it a fabulous stay, and special thanks to Peter on the front desk who sorted me a room change over a little issue I had with my original room, and the lovely and super friendly doorman! I found the room clean, comfortable and spacious and although there’s no coffee/tea making facilities in the room, they have free tea and coffee in the bar in the morning. Some rooms have a view of the Empire State Building! The bar is cool too and has a small nibble like menu.

Cons: There was nothing I didn’t like. It’s a heritage building so some things won’t be ‘perfect’ but that’s part of the charm!

Pros: We stayed in this hotel for a week and we can say nothing but that it was very good. The room was spacious enough for two people. We had two double beds. The shower was perfectly fine. The beds were excellent and very comfortable — we slept wonderfully. Even though we were on the fourth floor at the front of the hotel, we hardly experienced any noise, despite construction work going on nearby. The only small downside was that there were some little flies in the room, which seemed to come in through the bathroom vents. However, this was very minimal. Perhaps the vents could be cleaned thoroughly once, but overall the cleanliness of the room, the daily water refills, and everything else were very well taken care of. I would definitely stay here again. The location — just a few minutes’ walk from Grand Central Terminal — was fantastic, and everything is close by. In short, we had an excellent stay and would certainly come back again.

Perfect apartment in a perfect location

Pros: Perfect location, great atmosphere and easy to get to and from most places in Manhattan and greater NYC. We stayed in a one bed room apartment and it was PERFECT. Great size, good amenities and it was great having separate spaces verses one big room which is hard to find in NYC.

Cons: Nothing, was perfect

Recommended, with small room for improvement

Pros: Very well located, nice staff, right-sized rooms. I recommend it

Cons: As a 4 star hotel I would have appreciated more amenities, like slippers

Highly recommend this hotel. Away from the hustle and bustle but also so close to everything. It’s small comfortable and

Pros: Location is amazing. Quiet. Comfortable. Room was big.

Cons: Water wasn’t replenished daily

Great hotel. It will now be our ‘go to’ hotel when we stay in manhattan

Pros: The rooms were spacious, clean, comfortable and we had a great view of the Empire State Building .

Very nice hotel near central station

Pros: Very nice hotel in a great location near the central station. The staff are very friendly. The rooms are relatively large by New York standards. The rooms are nicely furnished and up to date. There is a small fitness room and coffee is served in the hotel restaurant/bar in the morning, which we really loved! We visit New York often and would book this hotel again anytime.

Excellent stay - would definitely stay again and recommend to friends.

Pros: Great location and very clean and comfortable room. The bed was really spacious and extremely comfortable. I loved the bar too.

Cons: The room was a little smaller than I expected and there was no view, but there really wasn’t anything I didn’t like.

Wonderful location

Pros: Amazing location and the most comfortable beds in the world.

Cons: Nothing.

Good location for a Christmas New York break.

Pros: Good location near to Grand Central . Rooms were very clean with modern bathroom . Good size for a NY room. Staff were very friendly and helpful.

Cons: Not accessible … steps at entrance so had to lift cases up and down, no alternative. No lounge/bar area. Agency of record is on the ground floor which is dark,loud and limited in terms of offering and not open all of the time.